Effectively Managing RF Design in Utility Metering Applications Print E-mail
User Rating: / 0
Written by Roger Allcorn   
Sunday, 31 August 2008 19:00

EMS companies can be the missing link between meter expertise and distribution.


RF-based products are being introduced in virtually every industry. This can present a challenge to industries now integrating RF on a wide scale. What are the typical challenges? Is there a role for electronics manufacturing services providers?

A good industry example is utility metering applications. A number of factors are driving increased integration of RF technology in such applications. These include:

  • Lowered R&D costs and greater availability of basic reference designs.
  • Increased interest from utilities lower cost structure through use of more intelligent metering technology.
  • An active pool of automated meter reading (AMR) specialized companies and increased focus on this area by large meter manufacturers.

This drives a growing market for companies with existing distribution channels. The challenge is meter expertise and good distribution channels do not automatically translate to an ability to easily develop products incorporating RF technology. In some cases, EMS companies provide this missing link.

Technology drivers. AMR and meter OEM design departments face a critical challenge that is actually driven by dynamics in other markets. RF acceptance in many industries is increasing. The reason is the cellphone market is saturated and semiconductor companies are looking to broaden applications for RF-on-a-chip to increase return-on-investment for that large development cost. This has resulted in overall decrease in both component and design costs. It is possible to design product by integrating off-the-shelf solutions. Semiconductor manufacturers are supplying tested and calibrated evaluation modules. As a result, meter OEMs can integrate the technology to their device with minimal RF R&D.

The fact that semiconductor houses supply the printed circuit board trace design that can be dropped into the existing design opens markets to companies with less RF expertise. However, it is increasingly difficult to prototype finished products because the accuracy and precision when placing parts for UHF-microwave RF products often dictates if they will work at all, let alone what performance they can achieve.

Business drivers. Another market driver is increased interest from utilities in offsetting costs through more intelligent data collection and billing activities.

Meter reading carries a cost that increases as fuel prices rise. Technology that enables data collection to move seamlessly from place of measurement to place of billing reduces cost. This seamless linkage facilitates a range of options such as time-of-day billing, remote cutoff/turn on of meters, load shedding, leak detection, customer usage profiling and meter security. One technique for this communication technology is mesh networking, but the actual model used varies widely.

As these mesh networks grow in complexity, RF frequency ranges go from UHF (900 Mhz) to microwave (up to 2.3-2.4 GHz). In these continuously available transmission networks, such as GSM, wi-fi or other bespoke systems (450-900 Mhz), meter data is broadcast directly back to a central office. A more localized approach involves fixed transponders and drive-by collectors to capture data locally and transfer to headquarters.

Eventually widespread wi-fi-enabled mesh networks will link to the Internet, transmitting in the 5-plus GHz range. While simplifying meter-to-central office linkage for utilities, this adds complexity to meter design as it drives PCB component miniaturization (e.g., use of 0201s).

Companies developing product for this market range from traditional meter manufacturers to companies that simply specialize in developing AMR add-on devices for meters. Common elements among these companies are strong distribution channels and an understanding of market needs. However, many are not manufacturing experts, per se. Instead, they team with independent design firms or EMS providers to access scalable technical expertise and manufacturing resources.

Addressing Technology Challenges

While R&D expense has significantly been reduced, RF product development efforts in this area typically require engineering resources focused on product enhancement, test plan strategy and test development. Third-party qualification in support of regulatory approvals may drive additional design spins. In short, bridging the gap from RF-on-a-chip to an approved/fielded product requires specialized RF engineering expertise and ultimately a manufacturing partner capable of supporting a high mix/variable demand technology complex production and test process.

From a design standpoint, higher RF transmission ranges force a more precise PCB layout. With RF or any high-speed digital technology, the length of the trace is a function of the wavelengths being sent. Size is shrinking. Every trace is a component at these speeds, rather than just a link. There is virtually no packaging. The product must generate sufficient RF power to work in the correct band, yet have minimal interference with other equipment operating in the same spectrum. Pad design is extremely important. For example, in one project an assembly malfunctioned because the original component layout was not generating the correct power and was sending out harmonics that caused interference. Moving one capacitor half a millimeter to the left solved the problem.

Component selection is also important and an area where value for price must be considered. The lowest cost components may not perform as anticipated or may have availability issues over the longer lifecycles normally associated with these products.

Integration of design and manufacturing resources becomes critical both in terms of technology and overall product cost competitiveness.

Test strategy should help ensure continued product conformance to appropriate regulatory agency compliance standards. Testing should provide an aid for the manufacturer to put in corrective measures to improve yield. The process should also include a feedback loop that ensures, as design issues are identified (i.e., component tolerance variances), information is sent to the design house to drive corrective action in the next design spin. This helps the design company optimize the product for manufacture. At the same time, while testing should be sufficiently effective to ensure products are compliant, it must also be cost-effective in volume production.

In the manufacturing process, robust inspection processes also can be critical because, when products in this application fail, it may be a noticeable compliance failure that draws the attention of not only the end-customer, but also that of the agency regulating the end-customer.

Partnering with an EMS Provider

While the term product realization is widely used in the EMS industry as a generic description of design-through-delivery capability, in this case, industry-specialized product realization is truly the service needed. Key benefits the EMS provider should be prepared to deliver include:

  • A robust product development process, which includes both support of conceptual design issues and the more traditional design for manufacturability/design for testability (DfM/DfT) expertise.
  • Ability to support needed prototyping for product qualification and the subsequent ability to efficiently transition to volume manufacturing.
  • Engineering expertise related to RF test strategy and test development.
  • Component selection recommendations that consider quality, availability and cost.
  • Ability to place fine-pitch components.
  • Ability to support software integration and other customization requirements in a variable demand environment.
  • Ability to provide required testing to ensure continued product regulatory compliance.
  • Ability to support post-manufacturing requirements such as fulfillment, repair depot and spares support.

EMS contributions typically are made incrementally throughout the product development and manufacturing process and over time shorten design cycles, reduce design to production learning curve issues and improve quality. The following example outlines a project outsourced by an OEM wishing to add RF technology into its system solutions for the utility market.

Key challenges that needed to be addressed included:

  • A requirement for a product operational life of 15 or more years.
  • Hostile operating environments that could include high moisture contact and significant temperature variations.
  • Different product configurations for different markets.
  • High engineering change notice (ECN) activity, particularly in relationship to software revisions.
  • Variable demand driven by utility ordering practices.
  • A regulated design that could require formal re-qualification if component substitutions were made.

The EMS provider managed mechanical enclosure design, design for testability and component selection. DfM considerations took into account the EMS provider’s manufacturing equipment constraints and processes, which were aligned with IPC design guidelines.

The EMS provider evaluated component lifecycles and approved vendor list (AVL) choices. In terms of component lifecycle analysis, semiconductors were the primary focus in potential obsolescence evaluation. Recommended AVL choices were based on price competitiveness, track record of supplier performance and availability. When component substitutions were recommended, the EMS provider sent samples and data sheets to the OEM’s design house for evaluation. This particular EMS provider also had strengths in custom wound coil design and manufacture. The design house specified the requirements for an inductive coil, but the actual bobbin was selected and wound by the EMS provider.

DfT was another area of focused collaboration. The EMS provider had expertise in both in-circuit test development and RF functional test and fixture development. As a result, it developed the test programming, functional test set and fixtures. It also made recommendations to the design firm for connector placement to support test node accessibility and optimum RF signal integrity during test.

Test development was an area of greatest technical complexity. Test node accessibility and RF signal integrity drove specialized focus in both the product design and test fixture development. Additionally, the test process needed to incorporate a software programming step.

Product life issues were addressed in the initial design process during component selection and qualification testing. A potting process was used to minimize/eliminate environmental exposure.

The EMS provider’s systems for configuration control and traceability supported the high levels of ECO activity and challenges associated with multiple product configurations.

Market drivers are creating significant opportunities in RF-based utilities metering applications. For OEMs, the trick to capitalize on these opportunities is combining existing marketing expertise with a strong team capable of rapidly developing, qualifying, manufacturing and shipping products.

  1. R. Allcorn, “Emerging Technologies in RF Design and Implications on Design for Manufacturing and Testability in Outsourced Production,” SMTA International, August 2008.

Ed.: This article is adapted from a presentation at SMTA International in August 2008, and is published with permission.

Roger Allcorn is senior product engineer-RF products at Syncro Corp. (syncrocorp.com); This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .



Eastern-US: China’s New Competitor?

Parity emerges among EMS Factories from Asia, Mexico and the US.

For the first time in years we see parity in the Eastern US among EMS factories from Asia, Mexico and the US. This EMS market condition will permit American OEMs (the EMS industry refers to OEMs as customers) to have more EMS pathways to choose from. Now more than ever, such EMS assignments will require deeper investigation relating to the OEMs’ evaluation of manufacturing strategies.

The Human Touch

For those who count on the electronics industry for big feats, it’s been a remarkable couple of years.



Advances in Concentration Monitoring and Closed-Loop Control

Contaminated bath water skews refractive index results. New technology can accurately measure aqueous cleaning agent concentration.

Circuits Disassembly: Materials Characterization and Failure Analysis

A systematic approach to nonconventional methods of encapsulant removal.





CB Login



English French German Italian Portuguese Russian Spanish


Panasonic Debuts PanaCIM Maintenance with Augmented Reality
PanaCIM Maintenance with Augmented Reality software provides instant communication and information to factory technicians -- when and where it is needed -- so they can respond to factory needs more...